Coronavirus Response

  • Home
  • A-Z List
  • About
    • About the NCC
    • Connectional Table
    • Staff
  • Calendar
    • Events
    • Google Calendar
    • Past Events
  • Churches
  • Contact
    • Find Us
  • Districts
    • District Office
    • Beacon
    • Capital
    • Corridor
    • Fairway
    • Gateway
    • Harbor
    • Heritage
    • Sound
  • Employment
  • Search

NC Conference

Healthy Congregations and Effective Leaders in Every Place Making Disciples of Jesus Christ for the Transformation of the World

  • Discipleship
    Developing Disciples
    • Christian Formation
      • Children
      • Church & Society
      • College
      • Creation Care
      • Differently Abled Persons
      • Older Adults
      • Spiritual Formation
      • Status & Role of Women
      • Young Adults
      • Youth
    • Church Revitalization
      • Coaching
      • Disciple Making Way
      • Evangelism
      • Grants
      • MissionInsite
      • Shift
    • From the Bishop
      • Church Transformation
      • Conflict Transformation
    • Multicultural
      • Anti-Racism
      • Asian
      • Hispanic-Latinx
      • Native American
      • Strengthening the Black Church
    • Stewardship
      • Apportionments
      • District Remittances
      • Financial Discipleship
      • Grants
      • Insurance
      • Mission & Service
      • Pension
      • Treasurer Training
  • Leadership
    Strengthening Leaders
    • Bishop’s Office
      • Appointment Book
      • Church Transformation
      • Conflict Transformation
    • Office of Clergy Life
      • Board of Ordained Ministry
      • Called to Ministry?
      • Extension Ministries
    • Board of Laity
      • Certified Lay Minister
      • Lay Servant Ministries
      • Local Church Lay Leaders
      • United Methodist Men
      • United Methodist Women
      • United Methodist Youth
    • New Faith Comm.
      • New Room Society
      • Our Communities
    • Conference Offices
      • Center for Leadership Excellence
      • Christian Formation
      • Communications
      • Conference Secretary
      • Connectional Ministries
      • Information Technology
      • Multicultural Ministries
      • Outreach Ministry
      • Treasurer’s Office
  • Service
    Ministering To The World
    • Local Outreach
      • Afghan Refugees
      • Church Construction
      • Church Loans
      • Congregations for Children (C4C)
      • Creation Care
      • Cross & Key Prision Ministries
      • Health Ministry
      • Restorative Justice and Mercy
      • Seed Funds
      • Mission Projects
    • Global Outreach
      • Love for Liberia
      • Missionaries
      • NCC UMVIM
      • Project AGAPE
      • Sierra Leone: Mission of Hope
      • ZOE
    • Disaster Ministries
      • Donate to Storm Response
      • MERCI
      • Response Plan
      • Response Team
      • Training
      • UMCOR Kits
    • Giving
      • 2021 District Christmas Offering
      • Advance/Rainbow Covenant
      • Apportionments
      • Give to Storm Response
      • Mission & Service
      • The Gary Wayne Locklear Mission Endowment
      • New Room Society
      • Special Sundays
    • Ministry Partners
      • Boy Scouts of America (BSA)
      • Camps & Retreats
      • NC Institute for Spiritual Direction and Formation
      • Partners In Ministry
      • Robeson Co. Church & CC
      • UMF
  • Resources
    Supporting Ministry
    • Conferences
      • Annual Conference 2021
      • Annual Conference 2022
      • Charge Conference 2021
      • General Conference
      • Pilgrimage
      • SEJ Conference 2016
    • Media Center
      • Catalog
      • Labyrinth
      • Ministry Tools
      • Online Resources
      • Weekly Newsletter
    • Online Resources
      • Anti-Racism
      • Archives & History
      • #BeUMC
      • Church Lookup
      • Green Church Initiative
      • Online Data Collection
      • Online Learning
      • Pastor Lookup
      • Ramus: Web Hosting
      • Video (Vimeo)
    • Publications
      • Appointment Book
      • Bible Study
      • Conference Directory
      • Conference Journal
      • Every Day Grace
      • Lenten Reflections
      • Mission & Service
      • Podcasts (NCCUMC.FM)
    • From UMC.org
      • Agencies
      • Communications
      • Discipleship
      • Finance & Administration
      • Global Ministries
      • Graphics Library
      • Relief
      • Status & Role of Women

Restructure

May 1, 2012 Leave a Comment

Expect to see proposals to consolidate United Methodist general agencies come before the 2012 General Conference floor this week.

The General Administration Legislative Committee adjourned almost a half-hour past its 9:30 p.m. deadline April 28 without recommending any comprehensive plan — including the two officially submitted and the unofficial plan — to restructure the agencies and downsize the agency boards of directors. Many frustrated observers called the committee proceedings a “debacle.”

“This was money wasted, time wasted; this is not the will of God,” said the Rev. Dale M. Weatherspoon, a delegate from the California-Nevada Annual (regional) Conference, at the end of the April 28 meeting. He is not a backer of a particular reorganization plan.

“We’re trying to do holy conferencing and do our best to be the best church we can be,” he said. “And that means clearly discerning God’s will; it means give and take. The last 15 minutes came down to who’s going to win and to maneuvering.”

Proponents of the Call to Action and Methodist Federation for Social Action plans — the only two that were submitted officially — can still bring their original legislation as it was printed in the Advance Daily Christian Advocate to the floor to be debated and amended, said the Rev. Alan Morrison, General Conference business manager.

Supporters of the Plan B legislation could still make a motion to the plenary session to substitute their legislation for the others.

Under the 2012 General Conference rules, the two officially submitted plans need 20 delegate signatures to be brought before the full body.

Meanwhile, proponents of the various plans have been in discussions about possible compromises. A reflection of those discussions will be printed in the May 1 Daily Christian Advocate.

Plan ups and downs

The three full days of the General Administration meetings had their share of drama, with the various plans each appearing to have the upper hand at times.

The Call to Action plan launched the conversations about restructuring and was endorsed by the Council of Bishops and Connectional Table.

But at the end of the April 26 session, a nonbinding vote found 48 to 35 favored multiple agency boards rather than the Call to Action’s proposed single board to oversee the work of multiple agencies.

The next morning, the committee, by a vote of 56 to 25, approved substituting Plan B — which consolidates only some agencies — for the petition on the Call to Action proposed restructure. The General Administration Committee then selected a subcommittee to work exclusively on reconciling the various restructuring proposals.

The 18-member subcommittee included three representatives each from the three plans, three people of color from the United States and six delegates from the central conference regions of Africa, Europe and the Philippines.

Plan B became the working document for the subcommittee. During the discussion, the Methodist Federation for Social Action representatives successfully made several amendments to Plan B.

Under the subcommittee’s final plan, most agencies survived as separate entities with 33 board members.

The three supporters of the Call to Action plan abstained throughout the subcommittee deliberations. They and fellow Call to Action leaders were already working on an amended version of the Call to Action plan to offer as a minority report before the full assembly.

By about 7:15 p.m. April 28, the subcommittee completed its work.

At that time their recommended structure was placed before the full committee.   A gallery of bishops, delegates from other committees, and agency staff now packed the back of the meeting room.

To their surprise, the full committee voted against the recommendations of its subcommittee and then voted down all other structure proposals.   By the time that the Rev. Fitzgerald “Gere” Reist came by the room to tell the committee it was past the scheduled 9:30 p.m. adjournment time, the committee still had not decided on a plan it could recommend to the plenary session.

‘God has a plan’

While the April 28 gathering left many delegates and observers dismayed, the Rev. Forbes Matonga expressed hope.

“God has a plan,” he said that night. “I think we were so divided, and there was so much insincerity while we were working. … Next week, I think we get to be sober as a church.”

Matonga has been a critic of the Call to Action process for not including any African or Filipino voices in its research and the initial development of its restructuring plan. He is director of Christian care in Harare, Zimbabwe, secretary of the West Zimbabwe Conference and member of the Connectional Table.

African delegates agree “something is wrong with this denomination,” Matonga said. However, he said, too many U.S. church members seem to be trying to manipulate the African vote.

Ronnie M. Mangune is a lay delegate from the Tarlac, Philippines Conference and a first-time delegate. He was a member of the restructuring subcommittee. He also expressed faith that God will guide the deliberations of the delegates.

  “No matter how people respond, at the end of the day, God will help the church,” he said. “God says, ‘Do your best; I’ll do the rest.’”

A UMNS Report  By Heather Hahn

For more information go to:

http://www.umc.org/site/c.lwL4KnN1LtH/b.7989685/k.1FD3/General_Conference_2012.htm   or NC Conference GC pages:  https://nccumc.org/gc2012/

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Filed Under: General Conference 2012

Helpful Resources


Church Lookup

Media Center

Pastor Lookup

Online Data Collection

Get Email Updates

Sign up below to receive email updates from the NC Conference. You'll get daily News & Events, messages from the Bishop and more.

The NC Conference respects your privacy. See our Privacy Policy.

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Vimeo
  • YouTube
Learn more about the NC Conference

RSS Recent Site Updates

  • Transition Fund Recommended Change Zoom Session
  • Study Leave at Duke Divinity School
  • Care4Carolina Prayer Breakfast
  • Resources for the Connected People of God #BeUMC
  • Immigration Pilgrimage to the TX/MX Border
  • North Carolina UMC Apostolic Succession
  • Clergy Care: Rest, Renewal, and Respite
  • AC 2022: Graceful Justice
  • Amplify Partnership Introductory Webinars – 5/17/22 – Afternoon
  • Amplify Partnership Introductory Webinars – 5/17/22 – Evening

RSS UM News Service

  • Churches condemn hate, urge action after shootings
  • More church support for African agriculture
  • Charles Yrigoyen remembered as pastor and scholar
  • Where do Korean Americans stand?

NC Conference of The United Methodist Church · 700 Waterfield Ridge Place · Garner, NC 27529
Phone: 919.779.6115 · Toll-free: 800.849.4433 · Fax: 919.773.2308

Copyright © 2022 · Privacy Policy · Powered by WordPress · Site Admin